MMGM and #IMWAYR (6/22/2020): Stargazing by Jen Wang (plus giveaway winners!)
Before we get started, the winners of the 2020 Books by Black Voices Giveaway have been selected! First of all, I am so excited to announce that 17 people entered in the giveaway! That is about twice as many as normally enter, and I'm so glad that so many people are looking to broaden their horizons and perspectives with these books! The books with the most entrants were Genesis Begins Again and New Kid, so I gave away two copies of those, but I also decided to give away two copies of The Hate U Give, as that had many entrants as well. I gave away one copy of Brown Girl Dreaming.
The winners of the two copies of Genesis Begins Again are...
Danielle and Kellee!
The winners of the two copies of New Kid are...
Beth and Elisabeth!
The winners of the two copies of The Hate U Give are...
Faith and Rio!
Finally, the winner of the copy of Brown Girl Dreaming is...
Congratulations to all of the winners, and thanks so much again to everyone who entered! Now, for MMGM and #IMWAYR, I am recommending the graphic novel Stargazing by Jen Wang.
I discovered Stargazing on Amazon and decided to order a copy, and I'm so glad I did! Stargazing revolves around Christine, a somewhat-quiet girl who has more acquaintances than friends in the Chinese-American neighborhood where her family lives. Christine devotes a lot of energy to getting good grades and playing the violin, but her life isn't hugely fun until she meets Moon. Moon is a girl whose mother has fallen on hard times, so Christine's family allows the two to move into a small guesthouse next door to their own house. Moon is energetic, fun-loving, and extremely friendly, and although it seems like Christine wouldn't be Moon's first choice of friend, Moon coaxes Christine out of her shell and into a world of fun. Moon even tells Christine about the visions she has of beings from the stars, who tell Moon that she belongs with them. When something awful happens to Moon, it becomes Christine's job to return the enormous kindness that Moon has given her.
I've read a lot of books that I enjoy, but that I wouldn't necessarily look at again. The strange thing about Stargazing is that, rationally, it has several flaws, but emotionally, I loved it so much that I already know I'll be rereading it in the future. First of all, Christine and Moon's friendship is one of the sweetest friendships I've ever seen in a book. The two girls have so much fun and bond so much that your heart can't help but metaphorically swell with joy (a feeling we could all use right now). One particularly sweet moment is when Moon introduces Christine to the music of a K-pop (Korean pop music) singer and then teaches her how to dance to the music. You might be thinking that a friendship between a quiet, studious girl and an exuberant, outgoing girl wouldn't normally happen, but you'll see in the book that there's a reason why Moon isn't best friends with everyone else already.
I also love the way that Stargazing depicts Moon and Christine's community. It is too often that people lump every Asian person together into a jumbled mass of stereotypes and cultural ideas. This book challenges those assumptions, in large part through the contrast of Christine and Moon. Christine's family is Christian, and Moon's is Buddhist; Christine learns Chinese from her parents, while Moon knows none at all. Seeing the contrast between these two girls and their families is a good reminder of how much variety there is not just between races, but between the members of those races. I particularly liked the way in which Christine's and Moon's parents are depicted. Christine's parents expect her to get good grades, practice her musical instrument, and learn Chinese, but they're more multifaceted than that: they have fun with her at several points in the story, and they're willing to listen to Christine when she needs to talk. Moon's mother flies even further in the face of stereotypes: if anything, she is a bit too hands-off with Moon, although she, too, is a warm and loving woman. This book is particularly fascinating in that, instead of being a book about the one Asian child in a sea of white kids, it's a book about many different Asian kids (and some white ones) with different beliefs and values who nevertheless get along.
There are a couple of other things I enjoyed about Stargazing. There's an interesting point in the book about how bullies are not villains, but are just flawed human beings like everyone else. I also appreciated that a popular white girl named Madison who attends Christine and Moon's school never became the villain of the story or did anything cruel; a lot of books equate "popular" with "mean," even though that doesn't have to be true. Lastly, although I say this about every graphic novel, I really liked the art style of Stargazing, which is expressive and somehow looks crisp and flawless even with a few stray lines.
As I mentioned earlier, when I think rationally, there are a few flaws with Stargazing. There are moments when the dialogue is a bit clumsily written, and the book occasionally tried to make readers take leaps of faith that certain characters would do certain things that I remain unsure were in character for them. Again, though, there are a lot of books that I read that are objectively almost-flawless but that don't, to quote Marie Kondo, "spark joy." Stargazing actually "sparks joy" for me, and it will definitely be going on my bookshelf for me to reread in the future. Stargazing only took me an hour to read (and I tend to move slowly through graphic novels), so its joy doesn't last long, but the great thing is that you could read it today (perhaps with OverDrive) without messing up your already-planned to-be-read schedule. With its sweet, compelling plot, excellent cultural depiction, and wonderful art style, Stargazing is a book that I am thrilled to recommend!
Update (1/2/2021): My rating is: Pretty good!
Update (4/15/2021): My rating for the graphic novel-averse is: 4!
I still want to read Stargazing. Thank you so much for your generosity! I loved New Kid and The Hate You Give.ReplyDelete
Great! Thanks for reading my review!Delete
Stargazing sounds like a beautiful story. I especially like the focus on friendship and the element of respecting diversity and cultural/religious differences in in others. Thanks for this insightful review into a book I'm adding to my TBR list. Happy MMGM & #IMWAYR!ReplyDelete
Happy MMGM and #IMWAYR as well! I hope you enjoy the book—it is definitely a beautiful story!Delete
Congrats to all the winners of your great giveaway. I have seen this book on a few blogs but didn't know much about it. The background you provided was perfect and the title is now on my future read list. Thanks for featuring on MMGM.ReplyDelete
Of course! I hope you enjoy the book!Delete
This sounds like a great story, especially since you want to read it again. Congrats to the winners of your contest!ReplyDelete
Thanks for reading my review!Delete
It's great you had so many winners! I have Stargazing on my list, and you've made it sound very good!ReplyDelete
Thanks! I hope you enjoy the book!Delete
Congratulations to all the winners -- you gave away some excellent books! I love to read books about the Asian culture and I like the diversity/differences that Stargazing shows among Chinese friends. Your enthusiasm sold me!ReplyDelete
I'm glad I could convince you! I hope you enjoy the book!Delete
Thanks again for the giveaway book! I enjoyed Stargazing, and I really enjoyed your review and thinking about books that "spark joy" for me--and how I really ought to reread some of those books!ReplyDelete
I'm glad you liked this book! I don't reread books very often, even though I always enjoy it when I do! Thanks for reading my review!Delete
Stargazing sparked joy for me, as well!ReplyDelete
I'm so glad! Thanks for reading my review!Delete
Its am.i.portant point to have stories that go beyond the stereotype. Thanks for the review.ReplyDelete
Of course! Thanks for reading my review!Delete
During the school year, my graphic novels are usually checked out by kids so I brought home some to read and Stargazing was one of them. Glad to know it sparked joy for you and other readers.ReplyDelete
Thanks for reading my review!Delete
Wow! That is a serious recommendation. It sounds like you really love this book. I will have to check it out. Thanks for your thoughtful and thorough review.ReplyDelete
Of course! I hope you enjoy the book!Delete
So glad to hear you enjoyed Stargazing! I did, too, and your review was spot-on.ReplyDelete
Hope you are enjoying your books this week!
2020 Big Book Summer Challenge
Stargazing sounds excellent. I LOVE graphic novels and love rereading good ones. I enjoyed your review and the fact that the book had some flaws, but that you loved it so much says a lot. Some books just hit us emotionally and we love them no matter what. That alone makes me want to grab a copy. Thanks for sharing. :)ReplyDelete
PS- Congrats to the winners! I loved Brown Girl Dreaming and am reading The Hate U Give now.
This book sounds like a perfect read for my daughter. I just requested it from the library!ReplyDelete
Great review! I loved the book too. It's one I feel I need to do more book talking about, it's been quietly checked out. Hopefully we'll get to see kids again soon!ReplyDelete
I think your 2020 Books by Black Voices Giveaway was a fantastic idea!! I'm thrilled to see so many from our #imwayr community winning and look forward to hearing more about the ones I haven't yet read. I think my son has a copy of Stargazing, so I need to grab it from him before the end of summer. :) Thanks so much for sharing!!ReplyDelete
Thanks again for hosting the Black Voices giveaway, and then chasing me down when I won New Kid.ReplyDelete